The Stormtrooper Paradox

  • Published on: 30 January 2017
  • Help me make more videos!
    https://www.patreon.com/popdetective

    The Force Awakens does what no other movie in the long running Star Wars franchise has even done before: it humanizes Stormtroopers. Strangely the filmmakers seem unaware of the rather profound implications their new narrative has for the rest of their cinematic universe.



    A full text transcript coming soon.

    PATREON
    This video was made possible by support from viewers like you! If you’d like to see more videos focusing on the intersections of entertainment, politics and masculinity, please head over to my Patreon page and help fund this web series:
    https://www.patreon.com/popdetective

    PAYPAL
    If you'd rather make a one-time donation you can do that via PayPal:
    https://www.paypal.me/popdetective


    COMMENTS
    YouTube comments are held for approval due to harassment of this channel. If you would like to participate in constructive online conversations about this video, please share it on your social media networks, or join other supporters on Patreon, where backers-only discussion threads are provided for each new video.
    https://www.patreon.com/popdetective

    FAIR USE
    All multimedia clips included in this video constitute a 'fair use' of any copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of U.S. Copyright law, which allows for criticism, comment and scholarship. Learn more about fair use with this awesome app by New Media Rights! http://newmediarights.org/fairuse

    CREDITS
    Writer/Producer: Jonathan McIntosh
    Motion Graphics: Jonathan McIntosh
    Logo Design: Justin McIntosh
    Music: Jonathan Mann
    https://www.patreon.com/jonathanmann

    Help us caption & translate this video!

    http://amara.org/v/73ze/
  • Runtime : 10:48
  • star wars Finn FN2187 the force awakens Stormtroopers

COMMENTS: 40

  • THE Scratchyscratch!
    THE Scratchyscratch!   2 weeks ago

    Still makes me wish the modern starwars movies had a more serious and grim tone, consecutively that is.

  • Nyneva Kyte
    Nyneva Kyte   4 months ago

    Oh snap. When your desire to keep beating a dead horse for the big box office bucks conflicts with your strategy for the inconsequential annihilation of faceless non-humans, I guess you just hope no one notices?

  • 0roseable
    0roseable   7 months ago

    Interesting watching this after the Rise of Skywalker, with more defector Stormtroopers. And the suggestion with Finn and the others that the force casued them to defect. Would be worth revisiting.

  • Bryan Hann
    Bryan Hann   7 months ago

    Don't forget: Stormtroopers, though human, are the enemy.

  • Michael Hutman
    Michael Hutman   7 months ago

    Mate I get what you are saying about the paradox but it didn't start in ep 7 of the movies .It started in the animation the clone wars. With troopers rebeling

  • Lord Vader
    Lord Vader   7 months ago

    We need content just about the struggles of being a storm trooper in really tired of jedi vs sith and we need to expand on things that aren't typical for star wars

  • jan
    jan   8 months ago

    you are right

  • RiverShortman
    RiverShortman   11 months ago

    5:53 you can see in the bottom corner a holo of a young Finn!

  • Ed el man
    Ed el man   12 months ago

    They should introduce elite troopers into the new films to show how really dangerous the new empire is

  • Ashley Engleman
    Ashley Engleman   12 months ago

    as we see in EA's star was battlefront 2 (which is cannon) stormtroopers deviate. most probably dont due to fear of what will happen when then do. but there are some who get away, like iden versio and fin.

  • CatLovr105
    CatLovr105   1 years ago

    This is true, but the clone wars animated series gave lots of character to the clone army. Example - Captain Rex

  • Michael Yzaguirre
    Michael Yzaguirre   1 years ago

    And here I thought the blood on the helmet was a Lion King reference...

  • Flávia Oliveira
    Flávia Oliveira   1 years ago

    7:23 OMG the Wilhelm scream! in what? 2017? I can only presume they still use it as a joke, right?

  • TheSurgeon13
    TheSurgeon13   1 years ago

    That'd be a good game idea: you play as a squad of renegade Troopers in the first order and try to undo or eliminate as many training facilities as possible only to die in the end

  • charles g
    charles g   1 years ago

    I figured the movie didn’t seem to vibe because it sucked.

  • s14zen
    s14zen   1 years ago

    I don’t understand why Fin doesn’t become the face of the rebellion or the model to show other Stormtroopers that they can change. He should Board-cast himself and explain how and why he defected. Also, wearing the outfit and fighting for the rebels would be cool. Other stormtroopers would be able to see one of there own on the other side of the field.

  • Lee Banning
    Lee Banning   1 years ago

    Similar to the original Robocop trilogy. The Robocop movies, not the remake have a hidden philosophy to them that no matter how hard they try you can not not squash the human spirit, It will always find a way to break free.

  • Daniel Daring
    Daniel Daring   1 years ago

    This is an interesting point of view. Thank you for sharing it.

  • Freak Lefty
    Freak Lefty   1 years ago

    There really should’ve been a scene where Finn doesn’t want to kill other stormtroopers, and is forced to, or something. Could’ve been some cool character struggles set up from it all

  • Vistico93
    Vistico93   1 years ago

    Ugh, your one line...that the Resistance could've been started and led by a corps of turncoat stormtroopers. Damn it, why didn't the writers think of that? At the very minimum it would explain the First Order's obsession with them.Because I've heard before that what the Resistance is and why we should care about them is poorly explained if at all in the films. The same with the First Order who seem like a regional power at best (considering they don't even warrant the attention of whatever the Galactic Republic is calling itself now) and why we as viewers should see them as a menace and/or worthy inheritors of the Galactic Empire.

  • Dileep N
    Dileep N   1 years ago

    Stormtroopers are all nice guys, they miss their shots on purpose so as not to kill anyone.

  • Master Markus
    Master Markus   1 years ago

    After reading some of the books, I really wish that Star Wars, particularly the new series, didn't have to be condensed into just three movies because the story as a whole isn't really the simplistic "good versus evil" of the original trilogy anymore. Characters like Finn really suffer from not having real character arcs, and you miss out on a lot of backstory - like, I think General Hux and Phasma are great characters, but you'd have to read some books to understand why I think that. The First Order as a whole gets boiled down to "evil" without any explanation of what they actually do_. Like, as far as the movies show us, they're basically bad because they kill a lot of people, but because of limited screen time we don't really get to know _why they do that.

  • noface181
    noface181   1 years ago

    finn is a fucking blessing and i adore his character and his story

  • episodenull
    episodenull   1 years ago

    "The filmmakers seem unaware..."Yeah, that's JJ Abrams in a nutshell.

  • notourz
    notourz   1 years ago

    This makes me sad thanks

  • Lester Seale
    Lester Seale   1 years ago

    Bruh, how'd you make me sad over storm troopers?

  • BrightBlue
    BrightBlue   1 years ago

    NO ONE is going to get this reference, sadly, :( but I love how they handled this arc with Thragg's children in the final arc of the Invincible comic. It was always saddening to see them die, and their heel turn was very believable. Wish Star Wars could've had the guts to do the same.

  • Devon
    Devon   1 years ago

    Love the transitions by the way. Very... Star Wars-y

  • SuperMichuPL
    SuperMichuPL   1 years ago

    Fuck! This is actually pretty teryfying... Great idea!

  • A Chaps
    A Chaps   1 years ago

    Did the storm troopers get benefits, like a G.I. Bill? And retirement benefits?